Thursday, 19 May 2011

Feminism


Feminism is no one thing, it is different things to different people. Although most see it as meaning the rights of women – whether that means superiority or equality, and whether that is best achieved by treating men and women equally or differently, depends on which feminist you ask. Whether men can also be feminists, and whether “positive discrimination” is at all positive are other questions without consensus.

One of the most high profile feminist campaigns in the art world, aiming in this case at the end of what they see as discrimination against female artists, is that of the “Guerilla Girls”. An anonymous collective of female artists founded in 1985 and based principally in New York, they have engaged in high profile publicity campaigns against such targets as art galleries featuring only male artists in exhibitions.

While there are many female photographers who identify themselves as feminists, Annie Leibovitz, Cindy Sherman, Nam Goldin and Barbara Krueger, there is no single style or single topic that one can point to and say “that's a feminist photograph”. Common topics that essayists on the subject of feminism point to are such themes as examining gender roles and seeking to document life from a woman's perspective, but those women who do not describe themselves feminists also photograph just the same things. 
 

So although there are hundreds of photographs by feminists, I remain unconvinced “feminist photography” exists. The image above is a good example, at first glance quite a male chauvinistic image of a scantily-clad woman in bright red high heels on the knee of a powerful suited man, is actually taken by Annie Leibovitz, a self-described feminist.

It seems therefore that just as Marcel Duchamp famously said “Anything is art if the artist says it is”, anything is feminism if a feminist says it is.

References:
Williams, Val, "Illuminations: women writing on photography from the 1850s to the present", 1997
Warner Marien, Mary, "Photography: A Cultural History", 2006

Biography 2 - Nan Goldin


Nan Goldin is an American photographer best known for her works giving an intimite portrayal of groups such as Boston's late 1970s and early 1990s post-punk music scene and the members of the newly vibrant gay scene of the same era. Her most famous work is undoubtedly the 1979-1986 collection published as “The Ballad of Sexual Dependency”, notably depicting from an insiders point of view the hard core drug use and the relationships of violent and agreessive couples she surrounded herself by after moving to New York following her graduation. Martin Parr has argued that this was the major boost to the personal snapshot aesthetic of photgraphy that catpulted the genre into public consciousness.

Goldin grew up in middle class Jewish family in suburban Boston in the 1950s and 60s, but her previously peaceful family life was shattered when her older sister commited suicide in 1965 aged 18. Most biographers her later choice of relationships and societal companions on this event to a greater or lesser extent.

Her early work, prior to around 1995, is dominated by hard realities of love, violence, sex and relationships while since that time her work has mellowed and includes subjects like babies, parenthood and family life. Topics that one would not necessarily associate with someone who focused on transexuals and drag queens for her notable works while younger. While attracting ciriticism for her works appearing to glamourise drug taking, she has spoken out against the “heroin chic” since the early 2000s.

This image, possbly one of the tamer ones from her early works, reflects the snapshot style taken with the available light in grungy surrounds that she preferred.

References:
martinparr.com – Official Website
Goldinm, Nan, Costa, Guido et al, "The Devil's Playground", 2008
Coast, Guido, "Nan Goldin", 2010

Biography 1: Martin Parr


Martin Parr is a photojournalist and documentary photographer from England who is particularly noted for his critial photographic protrayals of suburbia and suburban life. His approach to his work is to depict his subjects in an intimate manner in their natural environment, sometimes quite anthropological in style.

Active since the 1970s he cites being shown the work of Tony Ray Jones while studying at Manchester Polytechnic as being the biggest inspiration on his early professional career. A keen collector, the “garish” postcards produced by John Hinde in the 1950-70s are also cited as influential to his colour work.

This photo of Parr's of the Swiss Alps from his 1995 book “Small World: A global photographic project 1987–1994” illustrates his post-modernist approach to doucmentary photography. This is neither a portrait of the browsing shoppers, nor a classical landscape shot of the dramatic mountain scenery. It is however a portrayal of life as it is – a window on the world as he sees it. Yet it is more than just a casual snapsot, composed to show the juxtaposition of commerical tourism with the wilds of the snow-capped mountains beyond. It is a study of the apparent indifference to this grand vista that the browsing couple show.

This preponderance of documenting the real life does not win him acolades from all quarters though, with one Sunday Times article describing him as possibly the most polarising of all contemporary phographers.

References:
Samdal, Robert, "Martin Parr polarises the world of photography", The Sunday Times, 20 April, 2008
Martin Parr.com – official website
Parr, Martin “Small World: A global photographic project 1987–1994”, 1995.
Phillips, Sandra S, “Martin Parr”, 2007

Modernism and Postmodernism


Modernism is a cultural movement focused on the future, on social change, on technology originating in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. It was founded as a reaction against the more conservative Realism movement that preceded it.

To a large extent it is about context and needing to understand the context and the background to a work before you can understand the work itself.

The invention and development of photography largely coincided with the rise of modernism, and the technology was embraced as art by many followers of the movement. Documentary photography was apropriated as art as well as the abstract and avante garde.
Alexander Rodchenk and Jean-Eugne Atget are notable photgraphers of the early 20th century part of the movement.


Florence Henri's “Composition with ball and mirror” from 1930 shows the strong compositional aspect to modernist phtography.

Postermodernism arose in the latter part of the 20th Century as a recation to the then-prevailing modernsm. It strives against the hard classifications of modernism, and is more playful with meanings and cultural references – it's about works for everybody more than works for those who understand. It is highly represented in modern contemporary culutre's adoption of the everyday as a worthy subject. Where modernism adheres to rules and convention, postmodernism breaks free of them.


Japanese photographer Miwa Yanagi's image, from her “My Grandmother” series illustrates the freedom of postmoderinsm in photography.

References:
Roberts, Helene. "Art History Through the Camera's Lens", 1995
Warner Marien, Mary, "Photography: A Cultural History", 2006

Semiotics


Semiotics is the study of signs within a culture, particularly with reference to how they are used for communication. Communication is the exchange of information between parties.

Semiotics states that the information exchange is an exchange of signs – things that have a form (e.g. writing, an object, a gesture) and refer to something other than itself. For communication to happen, both parties must both recognise that the thing is a sign, and understand what it refers to. This is not universal – different languages have different signs for the same thing for example, and different symbols mean different things in different cultures.

The picture above is of a collection of road signs in Llanberis, north Wales. All three are dependent on the reader knowing the signs they portray, but to different extent. The bottom one is giving directions to the village car park – two concepts, a “village” and a “car park” that speakers of the English language recognise by those two signs, which combine to make a third concept “the car park for the village”. Speakers of the Welsh language recognise the same concept also by a combination of the same smaller concepts, but represented by different signs “maes parcio” (“car park”, or literally “field [for] parking”) and “y pentref” (“the village”). The white-on-blue “P” sign is a pan-European sign that also represents the concept “car park”. The arrow is a near universally recognised sign representing direction. The brown background to the signs represent another sign when appearing on British road signs – that the information shown on the sign relates to tourist destinations.

The middle road sign uses linguistic signs to impart meaning to a new sign – those seeing this road sign are being taught that from this point on the picture represents the concept they already know as “Electric Mountain” in English or “Mynydd Gwefru” in Welsh. Further road signs do not need to repeat all this information.

The top road sign uses no linguistic signs at all. Some of the signs are familiar from being defined as standard signs for use throughout Britain (e.g. the “P” and “steam train” graphics) but others are defined only locally on a previous sign, for example symbol left of the “P” - if you have not seen the explanations previously this sign is nearly as meaningless to you as “Rheilffordd yr Wyddfa” is to a non-Welsh speaker. “Nearly” because it is aimed at tourists who will know that there is a funicular railway in Llanberis and recognise this as a train going up a slope, and thus it's a sign that signifies the “Snowdon Mountain Railway”.

Even within a culture, signs do not work if you don't have the expected knowlege to understand the meaning – the associations that are provided by the signified are not communicated and the communication becomes meaningless. Comapnies spend lots of money on getting celebrity endorsements for the products they are advertising, hoping that by the association the values associated with the celebrity will be associated with the product. For example, a golf club manufacturer will spend millions to get Tiger Woods to endorse their product – hoping that you will associate excellent golfing performance with their clubs and so buy them to improve your game.

The image above is another example of celebrity endorsement. This time for “Swift Cover car insurance” (and it is only because I've seen previous adverts that I know this much), who will have paid lots of money to get this man to appear in their adverts. However as I had no idea who he was, the advert means nothing to me. In finding a copy of the image above, I've learned that he is “Iggy Pop” and although I know he is (was?) a signer that is the exent of my knoweldge about him and I'm still clueless about what message the advert is trying to say. I do not recognise the sign and so the communication fails. The watch he is holding is another sign, but this one I do understand - it represents time. 

Referenes:
Chandler, Daniel. "Semitoics: the basics", 2007.
Bignell, Jonathan. "Media Semiotics: An introduction", 2002